In a surprising turn of events during the 2025 NFL Draft, the New England Patriots made a bold decision by selecting Baylor wide receiver Tyquan Thornton over Georgia standout George Pickens. While Pickens was widely considered one of the top receiving prospects available, the Patriots opted to address their needs with Thornton, who was known for his blazing speed and vertical playmaking ability.
Thornton, a 6’2″, 181-pound receiver, ran an eye-popping 4.28-second 40-yard dash at the NFL Scouting Combine, one of the fastest times ever recorded by a wide receiver. This electrifying speed was a key factor in the Patriots’ decision to bring him in, as they sought to add a deep-threat weapon to their offense, which had struggled to stretch the field in recent years.
In contrast, Pickens, a 6’3″, 195-pound wideout, was celebrated for his exceptional ball skills, contested-catch ability, and physicality. He had been a dominant force in Georgia’s offense, especially during their national championship run in 2021. Many analysts and fans alike believed that Pickens’ more well-rounded skill set would be the safer pick, especially for a team in need of a reliable, all-around receiver.
The Patriots’ choice to take Thornton over Pickens has sparked debate in the football world. Some view Thornton as a high-upside pick who could emerge as a game-breaking talent if he refines his route running and adjusts to the NFL level. Others question whether New England passed on a more proven, polished player in Pickens, who quickly made an impact with the Pittsburgh Steelers after being drafted in the second round.
As the 2025 season unfolds, all eyes will be on these two players to see if the Patriots’ gamble on Thornton pays off or if Pickens proves to be the more valuable choice.
